Protected: Brick by Brick

This content is password-protected. To view it, please enter the password below.

Posted in home repair | Enter your password to view comments.

Fake Fire

My father loved his fireplaces. He would light fires on winter days in each of the three houses he owned during my lifetime, despite them all having central heating and air conditioning. I grew up helping him bring in wood, light, and tend many a fire. In my college years, one of the apartments had a fireplace, but I just burned a Duraflame log or two in it, and I never used the miniscule fireplace at my apartment in Oklahoma City during the winter when I was substitute teaching while applying for full-time jobs for the next academic year.

I moved to Bartlesville in 1989, but neither my apartment at The Village nor the house I rented in Pennington Hills had fireplaces. When I purchased my home in Arrowhead Acres in 1994, I was pleased that it had a woodburning fireplace with a natural gas starter pipe as I had been accustomed to at my parents’ homes. I bought half a rick of wood once, and a work colleague once gifted me with cuttings from her new property, but otherwise I relied on tree limbs cut down on my own property to fuel it.

I could go multiple years without lighting a fire, and in the past ten years Wendy and I have used it less than a handful of times. She was wary of the chimney, which had never been cleaned and had badly spalled house bricks on its exterior veneer. Minor efflorescence on the fire bricks in the firebox was likely from water seepage through cracks in the concrete chimney top.

Linear gas fireplace
Linear gas fireplace in Santa Fe, NM

Now that I am retired, I will be spending many cold winter days at home. I asked a professional mason to apply repair mortar to various spalled bricks around the perimeter of the house, and he inspected the chimney’s exterior. He applied sealant to the cracks in the concrete cap but left most of the chimney’s spalling brick veneer untouched since I was no longer interested in burning wood fires, nor in having an insert installed that used the existing gas line.

I didn’t want to have the flue cleaned nor hire someone to install an insert, such as the linear gas fireplaces we have seen during our travels, as neither real nor fake linear fireplaces do much for me. I prefer the look of a log fire with its crackles and hiss, and I wanted an inexpensive substitute that was dead simple to install and use.

So I opted for a LegendFlame 25″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set. I cleaned out the ashes from our fireplace and set the $260 unit into it, using pliers to bend one corner of the existing fireplace cover to pass through its electric cord. The included heavy grounded cord wasn’t long enough to reach the nearest wall outlet, so I purchased a six-foot extension cord of 14 AWG (American Wire Gauge) rated to handle up to 1,875 watts.

The matte plastic flame screen behind the fake logs is for flame effects, and it works fine for me although some folks opt to instead have the lighting effects fall on the back wall of their firebox. A remote control allows me to quickly switch among high/low/off lighting levels, six optional sound options, and to optionally activate its 750/1500 watt forced air heater. I made a video illustrating the various options.

My initial choices for the unit are to run it at the lower light level on sound setting #6, which is low crackle with wind noise on. In the winter, if I’m sitting near the fire I plan to open the glass doors but leave the wire screen in place, setting the heater on high. Otherwise, I can leave the doors closed and just turn on the unit’s lighting and sound as desired.

Bear in mind that a plug-in fireplace’s heat output is limited by the 15 ampere electrical circuit to about 1,500 watts for maybe 5,000 BTUs of heat, while an actual wood fire can output 20,000 to 80,000 BTUs and will feel much hotter.

Inexpensive units like mine typically use LED lights shining at rotating reflectors to reflect light onto plastic screens with a matte finish to create the flame effects.

Flame effect rotators
Flame effects created with LED lights shining on rotating reflectors [Source 1; Source 2]

More expensive units can use LCD displays showing recorded flame imagery, and “holographic” units use tilted beam splitter glass to make recordings of actual flames appear amidst fake logs.

Beam splitter “holographic” fake flames [Source]

The results can be quite impressive, especially from a distance.

Beam splitter illusion [Source]

However, once you know how the tricks work, you can quickly spot the “tells” of rotating elements and repetitive patterns or how illusory flames line up along one or more planes in a tableau. As with many forms of entertainment, to properly enjoy a fake fire, you do have to suspend your disbelief.

Posted in home repair | Leave a comment

Philips LED Evolution

Philips products have been a part of my daily life for decades. I have used their Norelco rotary shavers for 45 years or so, and their Sonicare toothbrushes since 2011. They were once part of my media environment, since in the early 21st century, I bought an MP3 CD boombox, a combination DVD/VCR, and a recordable DVD unit from the Dutch firm. However, all of those consumer electronics became obsolete and were given away.

Philips media players
My Philips media players and recorders

The company was founded in 1891 in the Netherlands by engineer Gerard Philips and his father, Frederik. They began as a small manufacturer of carbon-filament incandescent light bulbs, but they expanded into vacuum tube radios in the 1920s. Philips engineer Alexandre Horovitz developed the rotary-blade electric shaver, which launched in the US in 1939. After World War II, the company produced televisions and other household appliances. It introduced the compact audio cassette in 1963 and co-developed the compact disc with Sony in the late 1970s and the 1980s.

Philips 20th century products
Notable Philips products during its first century of business

Philips LED Light Bulbs

Philips products eventually illuminated my daily life at Meador Manor. In October 2012, I bought my first LED light bulbs from them, as light emitting diodes spread from indicator lights on electronic devices to home light sources designed to replace traditional incandescent bulbs. The old bulbs output about 13 lumens per watt and lasted about 1,000 hours. The early Philips LED bulbs output about 59 lumens per watt and might last 25,000 hours.

My first LED bulbs were dimmable, meant to replace a 40 watt incandescent bulb with 470 lumens of output, and the packaging explained their 25,000 hour rated life as them lasting 22.8 years if used for three hours on a daily basis. Those early bulbs cost $21 each at the time, and Philips fought the sticker shock by noting that they could reduce a typical electricity bill by $88 over their long life when compared to an inefficient incandescent bulb. However, they were quite odd looking compared to modern LED bulbs.

Early Philips LED bulbs
My first LED light bulbs

Light bulb gallium nitride LEDs emit a harsh, high-intensity blue light. So Philips placed yellow phosphor plates near the outer surface of the bulb, mixing the light into a warm and comfortable white light.

The bulbs also had massive metal heat sinks to help protect their internal electronics. I screwed the two bulbs into a lamp on a table beside my recliner, and they have been in daily use, for roughly eight hours on weekdays and maybe twice that on weekends, for the past fourteen years.

Lamp with vintage Philips LED bulbs
The 2012 Philips LED bulbs still working great in 2026
Philips and Cree LED bulbs
The Cree bulbs did not last as claimed

By May 2015, my stash of incandescent bulbs was thinning, and I decided to start replacing other incandescent bulbs around the house with LED bulbs. However, I couldn’t find Philips ones rated for enclosed fixtures. Consumer Reports led me to purchase 9.5 watt Cree bulbs for $12 each that output 800 lumens and thus were considered replacements for 60-watt incandescent bulbs. They had a glass dome, a heavy cast base and heat sink, and claimed the same 25,000-hour life as my earlier Philips bulbs, or about 25 times that of an incandescent bulb.

However, in both my enclosed and unenclosed fixtures around the house, the Cree bulbs did not live up to that claim. They lasted longer than incandescents but still burned out after a few thousand hours of use. The LEDs had not worn out, being far from their L70 lifetime at which point their light output would drop below 70% of the original rating. Instead, the bulbs’ internal circuitry, which converted alternating to direct current, had failed thanks to components like electrolytic capacitors which degrade with heat exposure.

By 2016, Philips had spun off its lighting division, which became Signify N.V. in 2018 but continues to license the Philips brand. Their later bulbs did away with the yellow hood and massive metal heat sink. The bulbs I purchased in 2016 and 2019 had a partial plastic globe over LEDs with the phosphor coating applied directly to them, along with a sleek white plastic housing that allowed them to mimic the appearance of classic incandescent bulbs. They were dimmable and rated for enclosed fixtures, and as the Cree bulbs gave out, I replaced them with the refined Philips ones.

Philips LED bulb evolution
The Philips LED bulbs used at Meador Manor have evolved over the years; I like a color temperature of 2700 Kelvin, which resembles that of a traditional warm white incandescent bulb

By 2023, some Philips LED bulbs had become full glass globes. I didn’t find an online glimpse into the workings of the heavy metal 2012 bulbs, and I like them too much to sacrifice one. However, I pulled out of storage a remaining old Cree bulb, a Philips plastic one, and a Philips all-glass one to illustrate their differences.

Three LED bulbs
Comparing a 2015 Cree, a 2016/2019 Philips, and a 2023 Philips bulb

2015 Cree Bulb

Cree bulb innards

The Cree bulb had a silicone rubber coating on its glass globe for shatter-resistance. Over time, it had changed color to now appear pink or purplish. I tore some of it off to reveal it had LED chips with yellow phosphor coatings arranged around a column.

The old bulbs were quite beefy, so I am glad that back in 2013, R.J. Littlefield dissected some of them, revealing the power supplies in the bases with their inductors, capacitors, resistors, bridge rectifiers and other chips.

2016/2019 Philips Plastic Bulb

My old Cree bulb weighted 5.7 ounces, while the 2016/2019 Philips plastic bulb was only 2.5 ounces. I placed it in a towel and whacked it with a hammer to pop off the top, revealing a plastic diffuser that I unscrewed to reveal it had sat atop 14 larger and 6 smaller LEDs.

Taking apart the plastic Phillips bulb

Back in 2015, Nate at Sparkfun Electronics dissected a similar bulb. He showed how the metal LED printed circuit board was bonded by thermal grease to a metal heatsink. Prying off the top of that revealed a ballast tucked into the base of the bulb with capacitors, an inline fuse, transformer, inductor, and transistors.

2023 Philips Glass Bulb

My latest Philips bulb weighed only one ounce. I placed it in a towel and struck that with a hammer to burst the glass globe, revealing four LED filaments instead of the big chips used in the earlier bulbs. Multiple microscopic LED dies are wired together in a long sequence on a transparent substrate made of glass, sapphire, or metal. They give off less heat, and back in 2019 Pulverrostmannen cut open the phosphor bar and extracted one of the tiny LEDs and got it to emit.

Those tiny LEDs are fed via a single circuit board tucked into the metal screw base. On the underside of that is a cylindrical capacitor along with a chip originally covered in thermal paste.

A 4,000-Lumen Bulb

Bright LED bulb
The LED bulb in our torchiere lamp

While there was immense progress on 800 and 1,600 lumen LED bulbs to replace traditional 60 and 100 watt incandescent bulbs, it took awhile for me to acquire a dimmable LED bulb bright enough for the torchiere floor lamp in the living room, which is on the same dimming circuit as the lamp beside my recliner. As the primary light source for the largest room in our home, for decades it had steadily consumed a series of General Electric 3-way 50-200-250 watt incandescent bulbs. They could output almost 4,000 lumens but only lasted about 1,200 hours at best, with the 200-watt tungsten filament inside them usually failing before the 50-watt one.

In 2022, I was finally able to order a SANSI bulb with 156 LED chips consuming 27 watts and outputting 4,000 lumens. That lasted about 3.5 years, and a year ago I spent $40 on a replacement. So far I’m breaking even on the parts cost of those LED bulbs versus their incandescent cousins, but I don’t have to replace them nearly as often and they use about 11% as much electricity.

Smart Hue Bulbs

Hue bulbs

In 2017, I invested in a Philips Hue Bridge and pricey Hue LED smart bulbs. They can emit a variety of colors and can be individually controlled with a smartphone app, Google Home, etc. For awhile, I had three of them in my bedroom ceiling fixture, but a couple of them burned out after a year or two. I switched to less expensive simple Philips bulbs for that fixture and used the remaining Hue bulb in a nightstand lamp that I included in some bedtime routines programmed into Google Home, as well as my morning alarm. However, I found that I seldom adjusted the brightness or color of that bulb, so eventually I got rid of the Hue Bridge and bulb and put a regular bulb in the nightstand lamp, which I then hooked into a smart plug programmed into my routines.

Divestitures & Licensing

Bad Philips radio
Crummy stuff like this has damaged the brand

A few years ago, I noticed some products with Philips branding that looked cheap and crummy. Here’s a video on a terrible Philips-branded radio. The internet told me that in the 21st century Philips had struggled to compete in the home electronics market, which was gutted by smartphones. In addition to spinning off its lighting business, the company transferred most of its television business to TP Vision and in 2021 it sold its domestic appliances business to Hillhouse Investment, again with a licensing agreement for use of the Philips brand.

So the Philips airfryer I bought in late 2022 was produced under the auspices of an asset management firm headquartered in Singapore. By 2025, Philips itself had only three remaining primary business segments, all in health technology. Diagnosis & Treatment includes imaging technologies, Connected Care includes patient monitoring as well as sleep and respiratory care, while Personal Health includes its toothbrushes, shavers, and the like.

So my Philips razor and toothbrush still have the same corporate parent, but the Philips branding on my light bulbs and airfryer was just licensing. That led me to ponder my first LED bulbs which have served me so well for fourteen years. They were rated to last for 25,000 hours, but I’ve used mine for over 41,000 hours, and they still look great. My $42 investment back in 2012 worked out quite well.

I’ve grown fond of those old bulbs, with their now-antiquated phosphor hoods, immense heat sinks, and durable internal components. So I went onto eBay and bought a couple more of them, new old stock. Coincidentally, that cost me $42 after shipping, sales tax, and a coupon. Not bad, given that the $42 I spent on two of the bulbs back in October 2012 would be over $61 in 2026 when adjusted for inflation. Those early over-engineered bulbs could be the last bulbs I ever buy for that lamp, and it will be fun to see if and when I have to put them to use.

Posted in history, home repair, technology | Leave a comment

Evading Loyalty Taxes

Loyalty taxes are a corporate practice of offering deep discounts on subscriptions to attract new sign-ups while quietly keeping long-term, loyal customers on older, more expensive pricing tiers.

AT&T logo from 1983-2005

It is especially egregious when, even after the initial discounts expire, newer customers stay on lower-cost plans while leaving unaware long-term customers on outdated expensive ones with no discernable difference in services. Companies employing that strategy rely on customer inertia, hoping that most people will remain unaware of the disparity, won’t notice slow price creeps, or will find switching providers too tedious, if it is even practical.

I first encountered this with AT&T decades ago, which was gouging my parents on an ancient calling plan while I was paying much more reasonable rates. When I saw my parents’ bill, I told them about the discrepancy and used their overpriced service to call AT&T and get them on a much better plan.

Back in 2011, I caught CableOne in Bartlesville doing the same thing to me. It was offering newer customers 10 Mbps internet service at the same cost as my legacy 5 Mbps service. I inquired over the phone, and they switched me to the faster service.

By 2022, CableOne had become Sparklight and was charging me $116 per month for 200 Mbps service while quietly offering gigabit per second service, to anyone who asked, for only $86. When I found that out, I went into their office and switched plans.

I’m not surprised when monopolists engage in such tactics, since their customers have nowhere else to go. Competition can help: once Bluepeak fiber optic service became available in Bartlesville, it offered the same download bandwidth and far more upload bandwidth than Sparklight but charged $60 per month while Sparklight was charging $94. I had Bluepeak installed and cancelled Sparklight, but despite a service call, our Bluepeak service had oodles of service outages. That led me back to Sparklight after a couple of months, long enough for me to qualify for an initial rate of $39 per month, less than 40% of what the Sparklight had previously been charging me, for six months. And after that, they only charged me $49 per month for fourteen more months. Last month, they snuck in a new “network management fee” to increase the rate to $52.92, but it is still cheaper than the unreliable Bluepeak service to our address.

My Digital Subscription to the Tulsa World

Tulsa World Archives - Page 2 of 2 - Rachel Wagner | Etiquette & Protocol

My latest experience with a loyalty tax was courtesy of the venerable Tulsa World newspaper. It was owned by the Lorton family from 1917 to 2013 and then sold to Warren Buffet’s BH Media Group until it was sold again to Lee Enterprises in 2020. I posted in December 2023 and March 2026 about the struggles in the newspaper industry, so I understand why the paper’s news staff has been whittled down from around 180 at one point to just a couple of dozen today across all roles.

I once subscribed to their paper in physical form, along with the Bartlesville Examiner-Enterprise, but once I got an iPad, I got rid of the physical newspapers. Back in May 2010 I wrote, “…I like reading the Tulsa World in regular webpage mode on my iPad with its Safari browser, although I worry about the World and hope they can get an economic model that keeps them afloat – I’m no longer a subscriber but still get all of their great content, and I doubt their online ad revenues are making up the difference.”

The paper did have to adapt to the new technology, and in 2011 they started charging $15 per month for their e-Edition, which would be about $23 per month in inflation-adjusted 2026 dollars. They kept it at that rate until 2015, when they bumped it up to $21 per month, which would be $30 today.

Things got weird in 2017, when BH Media Group started providing me with the e-Edition for only $3.95 per month, so about 19% of the price I had been paying. I naturally agreed, and they bumped it up to $5.95 per month in 2018, then $7.58 in 2020. In 2022, over a year after Lee Enterprises took over, the cost suddenly jumped to $20, and it was $30 by 2023. In 2024, they started getting sneaky, like the New York Times, charging me $34.99 every four weeks. They hope you’ll think of that as $34.99 per month, but 52/4=13, so they were getting a baker’s dozen of $34.99 charges in per year, for a net cost of $37.91 per month. In 2025, citing inflation and world tariffs, they increased that to $38.99 every four weeks, or effectively $42.24 per month.

A little over a year ago, the World’s executive editor resigned rather than implement deeper staff cuts, and still the latest cutbacks included columnist Ginnie Graham, an assistant city editor, a features editor, a features reporter, a copy editor, and a photographer. Ginnie landed at the Tulsa Flyer, a nonprofit with free daily news which launched a year ago with over 20 journalists. I can readily access three to five articles per day from it using Apple News.

The Tulsa Flyer has been posting 3 to 5 articles a day in Apple News

I’d been hanging onto my Tulsa World subscription in appreciation of the work of veteran reporter Randy Krehbiel, but its value proposition for me was in poor shape at over $500 per year. Bear in mind that unlike many social media freeloaders, I don’t mind paying for news. The Bartlesville Examiner-Enterprise is now a zombie paper, so I cancelled it. Thankfully, its last reporter created The Wiley Post, and while for now its online articles are available for free, I happily contribute a dollar per day to support its local journalism, given its importance for an informed community and good governance. The Wiley Post had 17 articles in October 2026, and ten of them were of great interest to me.

However, I never appreciate a loyalty tax. For years, the New York Times has repeatedly notified me of a large increase in my annual subscription rate, and I respond by telling their system to cancel my subscription. It always responds by offering me $1 per week, which was an 84% discount for 2026. If that tactic ever fails, I’ll just cancel them completely, given how little I use their iPad app.

The Oklahoman Incident

A few weeks ago, I awoke to a notification of “suspicious credit card activity” in the form of a $149 charge for USAToday Co Digital. Well, the USA Today newspaper was once completely free, and then it started charging for its app, but I cancelled that years ago. I told the credit card company to not pay it and to send me a new credit card. After I had breakfast, I realized that the charge was effectively from Gannett, which had acquired The Oklahoman newspaper. I’d been taken off guard since I’ve been paying $99 per year for The Oklahoman, and now they were trying to charge me 50% more.

Well, since I’m now a retiree on a fixed income, I had time and motivation to research my options. I discovered that I can access many of their articles via Apple News, which is part of my $40 per month Apple One subscription. Even better, I can filter their feed in Apple News by section, thus avoiding the many sports articles I have no interest in. So I went online and cancelled my subscription, and they didn’t offer a discount.

The Oklahoman via Apple News
I can access articles, by section, from The Oklahoman with Apple News

Evading the Tulsa World Loyalty Tax

That put me in the mood to finally deal with the loyalty tax from the Tulsa World. I couldn’t just log into my account and ask to cancel, as I have done annually with the New York Times. Instead, for years the Tulsa World‘s dashboard said I had to call them during business hours, but this time they also coughed up an email address I could write to.

So I sent them an email to cancel my subscription, and their automated email response offered me four weeks at no charge with the “Ad Free experience” added in. That’s only an 8.3% discount, meaning they would just waive the sneaky 13th charge in a year under their “four week” pricing plan, and no doubt once the month was up, they’d hope to be charging me more than ever for the new “Ad Free experience”.

I put my web browser into incognito mode and checked their pricing on a brand new e-Edition subscription.

Tulsa World Loyalty Tax

They had been charging me $506.87 per year for Unlimited Digital Access, and my cancellation led them to offer to skip the 13th annual charge to reduce that to $467.88. However, new accounts were available for $99. That is over 80% off.

The loyalty tax for the Tulsa World was pretty egregious

I checked Apple News, and it also has a Tulsa World feed, although I can’t filter it by section — it is just a Latest Stories feed, and doesn’t include all of their reporters’ work.

Tulsa World feed in Apple News
The Tulsa World feed in Apple News

I compared the articles available there to the ones in the latest Sunday e-Edition that were of interest to me. Two of the three articles on the front page were also in the Apple News feed.

Two of the three front-page articles were also in Apple News

Browsing through the paper, I found three more articles in the e-Edition that were not in Apple News: Randy Krehbiel‘s Political Notebook and a couple of articles by veteran reporter Steve Metzer.

Three more articles in the e-Edition not available in Apple News

So I decided to continue my subscription if I could get the $99 per year pricing instead of $506.87. I didn’t respond to the Tulsa World email offering to reduce it to $467.88, nor did I go online to chat with a supposedly live representative, nor did I telephone them. I just let my subscription run out on November 4, waiting to see if they would contact me with a better offer or improve their renewal offer in my online account.

The subscription expired, and a renewal link just offered the loyalty tax pricing. So I went into incognito mode in my browser and signed up for a new account with a different email address, purchasing a year’s access for $99. So now I’m paying $8.25 per month instead of $42.24.

I appreciate the challenges faced by the paper’s 11th executive editor, Kristen Wright. I believe her when she writes, “It’s a weird time for me. I just turned 50. I’m working more than I have at any other job, yet I feel invigorated, challenged and hopeful.”

I also appreciate her sharing in her most recent column:

Kristen Wright, Executive Editor of the Tulsa World

I get phone calls, emails and handwritten letters from loyal subscribers — some who’ve been with us 50 years or more — who ask me to take the Tulsa World back to the paper it was when they were young.

I understand the romanticism. I fell under the same spell, and it turned me into a journalist.

But progress and stagnation cannot happen together. When’s the last time you went to Blockbuster, bought a Kodak camera, got a computer at RadioShack, ran to Sears for a new lawnmower or typed on your BlackBerry? Each of these companies was an industry leader. Today, they’re footnotes in MBA programs about what settling into stagnation will do to a company.

So I understand that she is working hard to lead the paper’s evolution and hopefully ensure its survival. I doubt she has much influence on the loyalty tax that Lee Enterprises is imposing on long-term subscribers, but that doesn’t mean we should accept that tax. Go incognito and check your various subscriptions across services for loyalty taxes, and good luck on evading them.

Posted in random | Leave a comment

Scholastic Books

Book Review

Scholastic Corporation was founded in 1920, initially publishing a four-page magazine on high school sports and social activities which was distributed in 50 high schools near Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. It gradually added more magazines and then entered the book club business in 1948, and became a book publisher in the 1960s.

When I was in elementary school in the 1970s, we would get little newspapers called My Weekly Reader. It had originated in 1928 but was owned by Xerox throughout my grade school years, and I was familiar with it before reaching school age thanks to the Captain Kangaroo television show. Weekly Reader had a mail-order book club from the 1950s to the 1980s and was acquired by Scholastic in 2012.

My Weekly Reader 1973
1973 My Weekly Reader

In my later elementary school years, our teachers periodically handed out cheap, newsprint-style order catalogs from Scholastic, and we could circle favorite paperbacks which typically cost $1 or less, bring cash or checks from home, and weeks later a cardboard box would arrive in class with our purchases.

Eventually we graduated to TAB NEWS brochures for the “Teen Age Book” club that targeted kids in junior high or what would often now be called middle school. Mind you, we didn’t have Scholastic book fairs at my schools; those weren’t launched until 1981 after it purchased a California-based book fair business. However, our libraries and teachers always had us reading “Sequoyah books” sponsored by the Oklahoma Library Association.

TAB News 1973
TAB NEWS for summer 1973 [Source]

I remember Scholastic’s offerings of Donald J Sobol books. His popular Encyclopedia Brown books for juveniles was rejected a couple dozen times before he could find a publisher, but since then that series has been translated into a dozen languages and has never been out of print.

I was a bit disappointed at their tameness and simplicity, so I tried his Two-Minute Mysteries, which were more murderous. However, they were like text versions of the old Lance Lawson comic strip, and puzzles interested me less than novels with plot, setting, style, and mood.

Sobol books
Donald J Sobol’s mysteries

Recently I read a couple of old Scholastic books I found online, which are tiny drops in the ocean of content it has produced. The company now releases over 750 new titles each year and distributes hundreds of millions of books annually.

Danny Dunn and the Homework Machine

Danny Dunn book

A vintage Scholastic book with a familiar cover was Danny Dunn and the Homework Machine, originally published in 1958 as the third entry of a juvenile science fiction and adventure series by Jay Williams and Raymond Abrashkin. I think I read it a half-century ago, but I don’t recall reading another book featuring that character, who was in the fifth or sixth grade. Abrashkin co-wrote the first five books with Williams from 1956 to 1960, with Williams adding another ten by 1977, although he insisted that Abrashkin still be given co-author credit.

I was unaware that the book was turned into a musical children’s album, with music composed by Julie Mandel. I couldn’t endure past the one-minute mark, but should you somehow make it all the way through side one, then here is side two.

Little did I realize back in the 1970s that forty years later I would be tasked with providing access to a Chromebook computer for each of over 6,000 students in a school district and the consequent teacher training, support, and logistics that would entail. Danny Dunn and the Homework Machine is now almost 70 years old, and my curiosity was aroused as I remembered nothing of the plot.

Among the reasons I was happy to retire this year was the rise of artificial intelligence and the many challenges it creates for education — after 37 years of integrating technology into teaching, it was time for younger folks to lead. In my retirement I had time to explore if that old book had predicted some of the issues schools are now facing after almost 70 years of technological progress. I found that David Owen already pursued this topic in a February 2023 article in The New Yorker, but I decided to re-read the book myself. I skipped the musical version of Danny Dunn and the Homework Machine, instead borrowing a copy of Scholastic’s 5th printing from 1966 on the Internet Archive while also purchasing a Kindle version using $2 in Amazon Rewards Points.

The Kindle version was a digitization of a 1986 printing by Wildside Press. Sadly, that edition omitted the many interior illustrations by Ezra Jack Keats. Right off the bat, in the first chapter, text about a homemade pantograph was greatly enhanced in the Scholastic version by one of Keats’ illustrations.

illustrated version
A helpful illustration by Ezra Jack Keats

The authors acknowledged at the beginning of the book their gratitude to Miss Terry di Senso, who had guided them through two of the computers from IBM in the late 1950s, and to Dr. Louis Robinson, IBM’s manager of mathematics and applications, for reviewing and advising on the manuscript. They also wrote, “In all fairness to both Professor Bullfinch and Danny, we wish to point out that their position on homework is supported by Bulletin 1248-3 of the Educational Service Bureau, University of Pennsylvania.” Does such a bulletin, reputedly entitled, “What About Homework?” exist? The internet knows not, but later studies showed a negative relationship between higher homework amounts and student achievement in elementary schools, a small benefit to some homework in middle schools, and high school students who did 30 to 90 minutes of homework per night had higher test scores than those who did none or those who studied more than four hours per night.

Danny and his friends are able to speak their questions to the computer, and it responds on a typewriter. It editorializes a bit in its response, acting like a limited A.I. from the late 2010s. Professor Bullfinch explains, “The computer can reason…It can do sums and give information and draw logical conslusions, but it can’t create anything. It could give you all the words that rhyme with moon, for instance, but it couldn’t put them together into a poem.”

Well, in the 2020s we have A.I.s that can write poetry, compose music with vocals, and more. When I was 13, I had to create a poetry folder in junior high, and I judged my efforts to be nauseating. For your own health, I’m only reproducing the warning I provided on my folder’s first page.

Warning in poetry notebook
The warning I inserted at the start of my junior high poetry notebook

For fun, I asked four different A.I.s to compose a poem about the moon while drawing elements from Danny Dunn and the Homework Machine.

ChatGPT

Gemini

Claude

Copilot

Note the em dash in Gemini’s composition, which is currently a tell for some A.I. responses. Claude also commented on its creation: “A few nods to the book: the homework-doing computer built by Professor Bullfinch, Danny’s friends Joe Pearson and Irene Miller, and the story’s lesson that taking shortcuts with schoolwork doesn’t pay off in the end.”

Watson plays Jeopardy!
Watson beat the Jeopardy! champs back in 2011

About halfway through the book, one of the kids programming the computer to do homework comments, “You know, we ought to enter her in one of those TV quiz shows. We could make a fortune.”

Well, in February 2011, IBM’s supercomputer Watson defeated human Jeopardy! champions Ken Jennings and Brad Rutter in a historic two-game, three-day exhibition match.

The book concludes with Danny realizing that he and his friends had to learn a lot in order to program the computer to do their homework. However, there are plenty of caveats with that overly tidy conclusion, and the end of the book is now rather dated. The Professor programs the computer to compose a sonata for piccolo and bull fiddle, and Danny’s mother laughs and comments, “It isn’t bad…but it isn’t exactly Beethoven, either.”

The professor responded, “No. It never can be Beethoven, Mrs. Dunn. No matter how intelligent the computer is, it is only a machine. It can solve problems in minutes that would take a man months to work out. But behind it there must be a human brain. It can never be a creator of music or of stories, or paintings, or ideas. It cannot even do our homework for us—we must do the homework. The machine can only help, as a textbook helps. It can only be a tool, as a typewriter is a tool.”

However, 70 years later, the immense datasets and prediction engines in A.I.s can create music, stories, and paintings, and they certainly can do our homework with us learning very little in getting them to do it. The tells that give away that an A.I. created something persist for now, but some of the A.I.s have passed the Turing Test, understandably causing human consternation, trepidation, and discomfort.

I had bailed on Mandel’s musical after a minute of Side 1, but I had Suno compose this little ditty with a similar prompt to what I had given the large language models. Jeepers, Danno.

Just this week I heard about 20 seconds of a beautiful song at the end of a YouTube video. I spent some time tracking down a complete version, but I wouldn’t be surprised to find it was generated entirely by artificial intelligence. Recently platforms like Deezer reported that about 75,000 synthetic songs were being added every day, but currently fully A.I.-generated tracks account for just a few percent of total streams on major platforms. However, almost 9 out of 10 music producers are actively using A.I. tools in their workflows, such as for vocal isolation, mastering, audio restoration, and social media promotions.

Was this created by an A.I.?

The Riddle of the Lonely House

The Riddle of the Lonely House book cover
Scholastic paperback reprint

Another vintage Scholastic book that caught my eye, which I might have read as a kid, was The Riddle of the Lonely House by Augusta Huiell Seaman. The Internet Archive has Scholastic’s TAB Books reprints of it with cover prices of 25¢ in 1961, 35¢ in 1964, and 50¢ in 1968, but quantity prices were available on request.

The book was copyrighted in 1935 and 1936 and originally published as The Strange Pettingill Puzzle: Two Mysteries for Boys and Girls by Doubleday, Doran & Company. The second story in the original book was Calista, about a century-old doll with a strange message in a hidden pocket of her dress.

I borrowed one of the copies of The Riddle of the Lonely House on the Internet Archive and found the book an easy and pleasant tale. Each chapter had an opening illustration by Charles Beck, and it included a nice floorplan making it easier to understand where a hidden room was located.

Illustrations by Beck
Charles Beck’s illustrations enhanced the book, but the chapter illustration should be flipped right-to-left to better match the floorplan
1930s edition
Original Doubleday edition

Seaman published 42 books for older children between 1910 and 1949, along with many short pieces for popular magazines. In a detailed post, Christine M. Volk wrote, “In many ways, Seaman’s books are as pat and formulaic as the traditional ‘series books’; in fact, some booksellers who specialize in series books call them a ‘non-series series.’ Since the characters were different in each book, readers did not have the same impetus to collect them all, as they did with the conveniently numbered juvenile series, like Nancy Drew, Hardy Boys, and Tom Swift. Nevertheless, most of her books had the same comforting familiarity: the plot frequently involved two ordinary young girls, often with a pesky, but clever, younger brother or sister, solving a mystery that they just happened to stumble on (usually in a small town).”

The Internet Archive has several of Seaman’s books, and Project Gutenberg has 10 of them. I don’t plan to read more of her work, but if you are interested, Christine M. Volk’s wonderful post about Seaman includes a detailed biographical sketch that draws upon the 1984-1986 The Seaman Log newsletter for Seaman collectors which was published and edited by Donald J. Summar. Volk nicely summarizes Seaman’s output and offers some recommendations.

Star Trek Puzzle Manual

Star Trek Puzzle Manual cover

In 1978, Scholastic published an abridged edition of Jim Razzi’s Star Trek Puzzle Manual, which was originally published by Bantam Books in late 1976, when I was ten years old, as an 8.5″ by 10.5″ trade paperback for $5.95. That edition provided readers with plenty of room to write, map out mazes, and solve puzzles, but it was out of my price range.

Later, Bantam released a more affordable mass-market edition. It was pocket-sized with less than half the square inches per page. Thus spatially complex puzzles had to be resized or modified, and mazes that relied on fine details were cut. While the 1976 trade paperback cost $5.95, the 1978 mass-market paperback cost $1.95, and Scholastic would offer the mass-market edition for $1.25 to $1.50.

Trade versus mass-market editions
The smaller mass-market paperback edition was scaled down and abridged

Both versions featured Lou Feck’s splendid painting as cover art, which Bantam also cropped for the cover of a mass-market paperback edition of the Star Trek 4 adaptations of original series episode scripts by James Blish. I was excited to be able to get the Scholastic edition, but that taught me a lesson in economics when I realized how it differed from the trade edition.

Detailed maze
This sort of puzzle was omitted from the smaller mass-market edition

The Evolving Book Trade

While vintage Scholastic books have some nostalgic value and they kept some works in print, I have no interest in collecting them, although I am glad some of them have been scanned into the Internet Archive for online borrowing and that some out-of-copyright original works are at Project Gutenberg.

The internet claims that electronic books have had little negative impact on Scholastic Book Fairs, since print books continue to heavily dominate children’s literature. While e-books found a permanent home with adult fiction readers, print books still reportedly out-sell e-books roughly 4 to 1, and children’s books are still mostly physical.

The mass-market paperback has gone extinct, and Scholastic has reportedly followed the industry trend of transitioning to trade paperbacks, which have heavier paper, higher durability, and significantly better profit margins. However, that means many of their books for older kids now cost $8.99 to $12.99 instead of the previous mass-market pricing of $4.99 to $6.99. My guess is that has priced some kids out, given that 44% of Americans have trouble paying for basic necessities, which increases the importance of free access to books via school and public libraries.

I’m glad that librarians in my school district host Scholastic Book Fairs and that children in our county under age five can receive a free book each month through Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library, which is locally sponsored through the Bartlesville Public Schools Foundation. Reading has always been a big part of my life and foundational to my personal success and satisfaction. Scholastic played a role in that, both through the cheap paperbacks I could order and its publications like Bananas and Dynamite magazine.

Scholastic publications
Scholastic publications I remember from the mid-1970s
Posted in books | 5 Comments